Strategies for Weaning from the Pacifier: Options for When It’s Impacting Your Baby’s Sleep

Written By Deana Jagielo

The pacifier can be a lifesaver in the early days of parenthood. It soothes fussy newborns, helps babies fall asleep, and offers comfort during transitions or stressful moments. But what happens when the pacifier that once brought peace begins to disrupt sleep, especially when your little one needs it to fall back asleep multiple times a night?

If you're a tired parent wondering how (or when) to wean from the pacifier, you're not alone. Here are some options for when it starts to impact your baby's sleep. Decide on which strategy aligns best for your family, and the key is consistency and practice.

Why Do Babies Love Pacifiers?

Pacifiers tap into a baby’s natural need to suck, which is soothing and calming. This is especially helpful in the first few months of life when their nervous systems are still developing. For some families, pacifiers even help reduce the risk of SIDS in infants under 6 months.

But as babies grow, they become more aware of their sleep associations (what they rely on to fall asleep) and for many, the pacifier becomes the association. This is where trouble can start.

So When is it Time to Wean?

The short answer: when the pacifier becomes more of a sleep disruptor than a sleep aid.

You may notice:

  • Your baby wakes frequently at night crying until you replace the pacifier.

  • Naps are shortened because the pacifier falls out.

If you’re popping the pacifier back in every 45 minutes, it may be time to consider a weaning strategy.

How to Wean: Age-Appropriate Approaches

For Infants Under 6 Months

At this stage, it's usually okay to keep the pacifier if it’s working for you. However, if you want to reduce dependency, try:

  • Using the pacifier to calm, but not to sleep. Let baby suck for a bit, then gently remove it before they fall asleep. This breaks the connection between pacifier and sleep.

  • Replacing with other soothing cues like gentle shushing, patting, or white noise.

  • Paying close attention to age-appropriate wake windows and baby’s sleep cues, so baby doesn’t get overtired and needs the additional support of a pacifier.

For Babies 6–12 Months

Babies this age are old enough to start learning to sleep independently but too young to find a pacifier in the dark.

Options:

  1. Cold Turkey
    Remove the pacifier completely at bedtime and naps. Expect a few hard nights, but consistency helps babies adjust faster. Offer lots of comfort and be prepared for protest, especially if they’ve relied on it for months.

  2. Gradual Removal

    • Start by limiting pacifier use to certain times (e.g., only for naps).

    • Once they’re used to that, remove it from the bedtime routine.

    • Replace it with other consistent cues: a lovey, sleep sack, soft music, or a calming phrase.

  3. Teaching Self-Soothing Without It
    Begin working on putting baby down at the appropriate time, where they are tired but awake, without the pacifier. This helps them learn how to settle themselves.

For Infants & Toddlers 12 Months+

Older babies may be able to find and replace the pacifier themselves, so some parents decide to keep it until age 2 or so. However, if you’re ready to ditch it:

  • Involve them in the process. Read books about saying goodbye to the pacifier. Let them “mail it to a baby who needs it” or leave it for the “pacifier fairy.”

  • Give a replacement comfort item. A special stuffed animal, blanket, or new bedtime toy can help ease the transition.

How to Wean from the Pacifier Without Crying: Step-by-Step

If your goal is to wean from the pacifier without crying, the key is a gentle, gradual approach that builds your baby’s ability to fall asleep without it, while minimizing distress. This method takes longer than cold turkey, but it works well for sensitive babies or families who prefer a no-tears (or low-tears) transition.

  • Begin when:

    • Your baby is healthy and sleep is relatively predictable.

    • There are no major disruptions (teething, illness, travel, regressions).

  • For about 3–5 days:

    • Let your baby suck on the pacifier as part of the routine.

    • Gently remove it before they fall asleep.

    • Use other calming tools to fill the gap: white noise, rocking, a hand on their chest, or a lovey (if age-appropriate, above age 1).

    This breaks the strong pacifier-to-sleep association without protest.

  • Watch for Drowsy But Awake

    This age is perfect for starting to build independent sleep skills:

    • After feeding and cuddling, place baby down drowsy but not fully asleep.

    • Let them try settling with other calming inputs (white noise, your voice, or touch).

    • If they fuss, pick up and soothe—but avoid putting the pacifier back in right away.

    Goal: Help baby start learning to soothe without relying entirely on sucking.

  • Babies love routine. At this age, use the same calming cues for every sleep time:

    • Feed baby again? Even if they already (hopefully!) had a full feeding earlier in the wake window, feeding again can help relax babies. And if they aren’t too tired, hopefully they don’t fall asleep during this feeding.

    • Dark room

    • Swaddle (if not yet rolling) or sleep sack

    • White noise

    • Sing a calming song while holding in a dark room, then set down

    Doing this consistently creates new sleep associations that don’t rely on the pacifier.

  • If your baby still wants the pacifier at sleep time:

    • Let them suck for 1–2 minutes only.

    • Gently remove before sleep.

    • Offer extra comfort through patting or rocking to ease the transition.

    Do this for a few nights, then stop offering it at bedtime altogether—without a big change in how you respond to their fussing.

  • If baby wakes and cries for the pacifier:

    • Wait a few seconds to see if they self-settle.

    • If not, go in and soothe without replacing the pacifier.

    • Try patting, rocking, or letting them suck on a finger (your clean pinky pad side down) briefly if needed, but slowly fade that too.

Why Bedtime First Usually Works Better

  • Babies are more tired at night, so they tend to fall asleep more easily even without the pacifier.

  • There's only one bedtime per day compared to naps, which occur multiple times and give more chances for resistance.

  • Night sleep is more biologically driven and typically deeper than nap sleep, especially in the early part of the night.

Starting at night gives your baby a strong foundation for learning to fall asleep without the pacifier, and this success can often carry over to naps with a few days of consistency.

What If Sleep Gets Worse After Weaning?

It might, temporarily. The first 3–5 nights can be rough. But most babies adjust quickly with consistent support and a calming bedtime routine. Sleep often improves once your baby no longer relies on something external (like a pacifier) to get back to sleep.

Helpful Tips for Success

  • Start weaning during a relatively calm time (avoid travel, illness, or major changes).

  • Stay consistent: Try not to offer the pacifier “just this once” after you’ve begun the weaning process.

  • Be extra responsive with cuddles and reassurance during the transition.

  • Consider sleep training support if your baby is struggling with independent sleep after the pacifier is gone.

Final Thoughts

Weaning from the pacifier can feel like a big step, but it’s a healthy one when it's interfering with your baby’s ability to sleep through the night. Like most parenting milestones, it’s a process that takes time, consistency, and compassion—for your baby and yourself.

Your baby can learn to sleep well without it—and so can you. Give yourself grace and hang in there, during the transition.

Want to learn more about baby’s natural sleep patterns, from birth and beyond?

Cheering for all parents!

Deana

Deana Jagielo
Next

Why Postpartum Support Matters More Than a Pinterest-Worthy Baby Shower